Supplement given to
polo horses incorrectly made
Source: Associated Press
April 23, 2009
Update to 21 Apr 09 story:
21 prized polo ponies die at Palm
WEST PALM BEACH, Fla. (AP) -- Unable
to legally bring a supplement into the U.S. to make their horses more
resilient, a Venezuelan polo team used another way to get ready for a
champion match: Have a pharmacy mix up the concoction.
What happened next, though, was disastrous. The chemicals were mixed
wrong, and 21 horses given the brew died in rapid succession, some
collapsing just before taking the field in a championship polo match.
The others fell soon after, one by one, shocking a well-heeled crowd
gathered to watch the U.S. Open at the International Polo Club Palm
Beach in Wellington.
The Lechuza polo team had hoped to get a compound similar to a
name-brand supplement used safely around the world to help horses with
exhaustion but hasn't been approved by the Food and Drug Administration.
Veterinarians commonly turn to compounding pharmacies for medications
that can't be found on shelves, but the dispensaries can only recreate
unapproved drugs in limited circumstances.
A Florida pharmacy that mixed the medication said Thursday that an
internal review found "the strength of an ingredient in the medication
was incorrect." Jennifer Beckett, chief operating officer for Franck's
Pharmacy in Ocala, Fla., would not say whether the incorrect amount was
specified in the order that came from a Florida veterinarian.
Lechuza said the order was for a compound similar to Biodyl, a
supplement that includes vitamins and minerals. The team has been using
the supplement for many years without problems, but typically uses the
manufactured version instead of going to compounding pharmacies.
"Only horses treated with the compound became sick and died within three
hours of treatment," Lechuza said in a statement. "Other horses that
were not treated remain healthy and normal."
While Biodyl isn't approved in the U.S., the supplement made in France
by Duluth, Ga.-based animal pharmaceutical firm Merial Ltd. is widely
used abroad. The president of the Agentine Equine Veterinarian
Association, Fernando Ruiz, said the supplement is commonly used on
horses that compete there, and he's not aware of any deaths.
It wasn't clear how closely Franck's mixture came to the name-brand
drug, though. Lechuza said what they ordered was supposed to contain
vitamin B, potassium, magnesium and selenium, a mineral that can be
toxic in high doses.
Compound pharmacies can, among other things, add flavor, make substances
into a powder or liquid or remove a certain compound that may have an
adverse reaction in different animal species.
FDA spokeswoman Siobhan DeLancey said the agency's interest is now
"heightened" with news the deaths could have been caused by a medical
mistake at a pharmacy - one that not only produces drugs for animals,
but also people.
Florida's State Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and the
Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office are also investigating the deaths,
and the pharmacy and polo team said they're cooperating.
Back on the field at the club, matches resumed for the first time since
the deaths with a moment of silence and a prayer. Flowers were laid on a
pond bordering the field.
"It's tragic for the horse world," said Dorothy Hungerford, of
Wrightsville, NC. "This is a shock."
Meanwhile, the state agriculture department wouldn't comment on the
latest news, but said testing for chemicals in the horses' blood and
tissue continued. They hoped to have some results by Friday. Necropsies
of the 21 horses found internal bleeding, some in the lungs, but offered
no definitive clues to the cause of death.
On its Web site, the FDA says it generally defers to state authorities
to regulate compounding of drugs by veterinarians and pharmacists but
would "seriously consider enforcement action" if one of the pharmacies
breaks federal law. It isn't yet clear if Franck's broke the law. The
pharmacy has had no complaints lodged against it, according to the
Florida Department of Health.
A veterinarian not involved in the case said laws pertaining to
compounding are unclear, and there is little oversight.
"It's confusing to all of us," said Miami veterinarian Zachary Franklin.
"We're not lawyers, we're veterinarians.
"Almost no one follows the exact letter of the law," he added.
Franklin said veterinarians often turn to compounding pharmacies to
recreate drugs such as antibiotics, but it is much less common to
compound vitamin and mineral supplements, because the ingredients are
usually readily available.
"I don't know what it is about this Biodyl that they like so much,"
Franklin said. "There probably is no good scientific reason to do that."
While polo's U.S. governing body doesn't test horses for drugs,
officials in horse racing wouldn't bother checking for the ingredients
of Biodyl, said the head of a group that helps develop policies for
regulating the racing industry.
"There's nothing in it that would be worth testing for in terms of
performance," said Scot Waterman, the executive director of the Racing
Medication and Testing Consortium. "It's B vitamins and a mineral."
He said there's some concern in his industry about compounding
pharmacies, which can be difficult to monitor.
"There are FDA rules on what can and cannot be compounded but there is
little oversight," Waterman said. "They play a very important role for
the equine practitioner but there is also potentially a dark side to the
articles, stories, jokes please send them to firstname.lastname@example.org.
Please includes your name, e-mail
address, other contact details and source of article.